Postal voting fraud
+3
cyfrifia
Jeanie
Hinch
7 posters
Page 1 of 1
Postal voting fraud
Interesting programme on this on Radio4's 'File On Four's programme. Worth listening to on BBC iPlayer. So blatantly done in some areas. Same handwriting, same sized crosses, same pen etc. You can spot the suspect forms a mile away according to one person interviewed. Heavily linked to particular wards with high proportion of immigrant voters allegedly.
Nothing likely to be done before next election unfortunately. Will be interesting to see any changes in results when party workers are banned from collecting 'completed' forms.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-26520836
Hinch- Spaceship Commander
- Posts : 1927
Join date : 2012-09-05
Location : Stradhoughton
Re: Postal voting fraud
I can 100% relate to this in my last election campaign. I reported all the facts to Council and Police with the evidence, but sadly nothing again was done. Why has this borough not got the balls to stand up against Asian politics ? and, sad to say, my confidence in politics has now gone. I have seen votes tip-exed, postal votes collected ,and one of the more worrying "Temporary postal votes collected in bulk on the day and Asian men voting on white girls cards; " the Candidate coming into polling stations with temporary votes 2 for her and 2 for her aid ! 50 temporary votes in one ward should show a cause for concern ???
Jeanie- Officer of the Watch
- Posts : 908
Join date : 2012-09-05
Location : Smallbridge Rochdale
Re: Postal voting fraud
Any Scottish people living in England who try to do postal votes in the Independence referendum may be fined £5000 and sent to jail for a year.
http://www.heraldscotland.com/politics/referendum-news/armchair-voters-could-swing-it.23509729
That seems a bit harsh, why shouldn't Scottish voters be given similar cultural sensitivity consideration?
cyfrifia- Time Lord
- Posts : 3139
Join date : 2012-09-16
Location : Todmorden
Re: Postal voting fraud
With enough feet 'under the table' it is a simple matter to turn back the clock to 'rotten' wards. You're dealing with a different culture. That takes time to eradicate what has been the norm. Bribery and corruption are seen as 'normal' in many Asian countries. Getting what you want, in this case your man 'in', is all that matters. No holds barred so to speak. You can't blame the perpetrators - it's the system that allows it that's at fault.
Atlas- Time Lord
- Posts : 3032
Join date : 2012-09-06
Location : Wales
Re: Postal voting fraud
An excellent insight from the Indie here from 2012.
http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/commentators/mary-ann-sieghart/mary-ann-sieghart-how-dodgy-postal-votes-may-decide-our-next-government-7646617.html
Also worth checking out the 2005 Birmingham case in which a vote-rigging factory was set up in a disused warehouse.
My own fear is that usually, the police and returning officers run a mile when allegations are made and the press are often too shy to report it.
I think there is little doubt that Rochdale is far from having clean hands in this respect.
http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/commentators/mary-ann-sieghart/mary-ann-sieghart-how-dodgy-postal-votes-may-decide-our-next-government-7646617.html
Also worth checking out the 2005 Birmingham case in which a vote-rigging factory was set up in a disused warehouse.
My own fear is that usually, the police and returning officers run a mile when allegations are made and the press are often too shy to report it.
I think there is little doubt that Rochdale is far from having clean hands in this respect.
Hinch- Spaceship Commander
- Posts : 1927
Join date : 2012-09-05
Location : Stradhoughton
Re: Postal voting fraud
I can imagine the astonishment on some people's faces when they learned how the postal vote system worked and realised within a few seconds how easy it would be to manipulate. I can't believe it is still allowed in its present form.
Dalelad- Admin
- Posts : 345
Join date : 2012-09-05
Age : 59
Re: Postal voting fraud
I've just listened to the Radio 4 programme and it makes some startling comments on how robust (or not) our voting system is. I still think that it concentrated on the wrong issue, though.
Out-and-out ballot stealing is a scandal that needs far tougher measures to try to eradicate it but, as the programme said, it is rare and also quite difficult to organise on any scale. With postal votes it is a lot easier and with the huge increase in the numbers of postal voters it has also become seen as more worthwhile and harder to monitor. The Labour government were warned about all this when they pushed the legislation through Parliament but chose to ignore it. In 2004 they even introduced 100% postal voting in 'pilot' areas of the UK that were mostly where there were local elections in Labour-leaning authorities on the same day as the Euro-elections. This is when Hinch's example of vote stealing on an industrial scale occurred in Birmingham and a vote-processing factory had been set up under some railway arches. But this is still fare from the main problem.
I was looking recently at some online copies of The Times from the mid 19th century. After the municipal elections each year there would be a report covering several columns of the newspaper each year simply listing the elections that were going to be disputed in court. For over a hundred years these dwindled away to almost none and then recently there have been a slowly rising trickle of cases again.
It suddenly dawned on me the reason why. In the mid 19th century there was no such thing as a secret ballot and for many people in the electorate (those with postal votes) the same is true again. Court cases had trailed off because there was little point in treating, bribing or intimidating a voter when you couldn't know how they voted anyway. Well, now you can. The sanctity of the polling booth has been removed and voters are now subject to all sorts of both malign and benign influences in how they cast their ballot.
Out-and-out ballot stealing is a scandal that needs far tougher measures to try to eradicate it but, as the programme said, it is rare and also quite difficult to organise on any scale. With postal votes it is a lot easier and with the huge increase in the numbers of postal voters it has also become seen as more worthwhile and harder to monitor. The Labour government were warned about all this when they pushed the legislation through Parliament but chose to ignore it. In 2004 they even introduced 100% postal voting in 'pilot' areas of the UK that were mostly where there were local elections in Labour-leaning authorities on the same day as the Euro-elections. This is when Hinch's example of vote stealing on an industrial scale occurred in Birmingham and a vote-processing factory had been set up under some railway arches. But this is still fare from the main problem.
I was looking recently at some online copies of The Times from the mid 19th century. After the municipal elections each year there would be a report covering several columns of the newspaper each year simply listing the elections that were going to be disputed in court. For over a hundred years these dwindled away to almost none and then recently there have been a slowly rising trickle of cases again.
It suddenly dawned on me the reason why. In the mid 19th century there was no such thing as a secret ballot and for many people in the electorate (those with postal votes) the same is true again. Court cases had trailed off because there was little point in treating, bribing or intimidating a voter when you couldn't know how they voted anyway. Well, now you can. The sanctity of the polling booth has been removed and voters are now subject to all sorts of both malign and benign influences in how they cast their ballot.
Prudence Tempered- Crew
- Posts : 166
Join date : 2012-09-27
Re: Postal voting fraud
Maybe the reasons for having a postal vote need to be re-examined.
keithatrochdale- Crew
- Posts : 198
Join date : 2012-09-07
Location : Rochdale
Re: Postal voting fraud
A very well-being meaning piece of legislation, agreed in principle by all parties designed to encourage more participation in the democratic process. I signed up because of various disability issues and access to my Polling Station. Now, it is simply more convenient to me rather than filling any real need. Needless to say, my completed form goes straight into the Royal Mail box with no friendly and possibly corrupt intervention by third parties.
However, the detail was badly thought out and is wide open to abuse by party workers and others. A national scandal yet to be addressed and often deemed as being 'too hot to handle'; due in no small part to cultural connections.
In Rochdale, everyone knows its going on, various concerns have been raised but nothing has been done.
The situation as it stands amounts to an open invitation to commit fraud. An invitation willingly and repeatedly accepted.
It would not solve all the issues but as a start, no party worker should be allowed to handle any filled, incomplete or blank ballot papers other than their own and it should be a serious criminal offence to do so.
However, the detail was badly thought out and is wide open to abuse by party workers and others. A national scandal yet to be addressed and often deemed as being 'too hot to handle'; due in no small part to cultural connections.
In Rochdale, everyone knows its going on, various concerns have been raised but nothing has been done.
The situation as it stands amounts to an open invitation to commit fraud. An invitation willingly and repeatedly accepted.
It would not solve all the issues but as a start, no party worker should be allowed to handle any filled, incomplete or blank ballot papers other than their own and it should be a serious criminal offence to do so.
Hinch- Spaceship Commander
- Posts : 1927
Join date : 2012-09-05
Location : Stradhoughton
Re: Postal voting fraud
"The detail was badly thought out." Might make a suitable inscription above the entrance door to Parliament.
cyfrifia- Time Lord
- Posts : 3139
Join date : 2012-09-16
Location : Todmorden
Re: Postal voting fraud
Key point: It was drawn up by politicians. The details should have been left to independent commissioners, if such a thing exists.
Hinch- Spaceship Commander
- Posts : 1927
Join date : 2012-09-05
Location : Stradhoughton
Re: Postal voting fraud
Hinch wrote:It would not solve all the issues but as a start, no party worker should be allowed to handle any filled, incomplete or blank ballot papers other than their own and it should be a serious criminal offence to do so.[/size]
It's already a flagrant breach of the Electoral Commission's Code of Conduct (paragraphs 20 an 21) for any party worker or candidate's agent to do any of this. But I agree, the sooner it is incorporated into the actual law the better - along with bringing back the original criteria for being allowed to vote by post.
Prudence Tempered- Crew
- Posts : 166
Join date : 2012-09-27
Re: Postal voting fraud
Codes of Conduct rarely work. As you say, we need legislation with teeth AND the will and resources to enforce it.
And yes, criteria for applying needs to be tightened up considerably.
And yes, criteria for applying needs to be tightened up considerably.
Hinch- Spaceship Commander
- Posts : 1927
Join date : 2012-09-05
Location : Stradhoughton
Re: Postal voting fraud
There already is quite a lot of legislation, but you're right to suggest that it's almost worthless without the will to employ it.
I have probably mentioned this before but there was a case in a neighbouring borough a few years ago where suspicious patterns in postal vote applications were reported to the police who then dutifully had all the postal votes from one polling district were fingerprinted when they were returned. Over 150 of them had the same person's fingerprints on them and yet the CPS decided not to proceed with the case any further because it "wasn't in the public interest".
And this year in Rochdale I hope the sales of Tippex are being carefully monitored, especially if it is being bought by the bucketful.
I have probably mentioned this before but there was a case in a neighbouring borough a few years ago where suspicious patterns in postal vote applications were reported to the police who then dutifully had all the postal votes from one polling district were fingerprinted when they were returned. Over 150 of them had the same person's fingerprints on them and yet the CPS decided not to proceed with the case any further because it "wasn't in the public interest".
And this year in Rochdale I hope the sales of Tippex are being carefully monitored, especially if it is being bought by the bucketful.
Prudence Tempered- Crew
- Posts : 166
Join date : 2012-09-27
Re: Postal voting fraud
Just received my postal voting forms for the European MP - - - ! But - But I don't want a European MP! In this day of mass surveillance and super-duper technology you would think they would 'know' that - surely???
Atlas- Time Lord
- Posts : 3032
Join date : 2012-09-06
Location : Wales
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|